A Critique in Need of Critique

Abstract

Is it really necessary to add something like the Health Impact Fund to the existing global patent system We can divide this question into two parts. First, is there something seriously wrong with the status quo and, if so, what exactly is it Second, how do we best go about solving the problem; that is, how does the design of the reform proposal address the flaws in the status quo Jorn Sonderholm, in his critique of the Health Impact Fund, or HIF, raises both of these issues. These criticisms afford us the opportunity to reaffirm our commitment to ameliorating glaring problems with the current system for incentivizing R&D for essential medicines, and to clarify why we believe the HIF is exactly what the world needs.