SN 1991bg: A Type IA Supernova With a Difference

Abstract

We present 13 spectra and 31 photometric observations covering the first 150 days of SN 1991bg in NGC 4374 (M 84). Although SN 1991bg was a type Ia supernova displaying the characteristic Si II absorption at 6150 A near maximum and the Fe emission lines at late phases, it varied from the well-defined norm for SNe Ia in several important respects. The peculiarities include faster declines in the B and V light curves after maximum, a distinct color evolution, a very red B - V color near maximum, relatively faint peak luminosity, a distinct spectral evolution, and a short peak phase. The narrow peak of the luminosity and the rapid declines of the light curves suggest a smaller mass in the ejecta and larger energy losses than for most SNe Ia. The unusually red color at maximum is not a result of normal extinction, since SN 1991bg was as blue as other SNe Ia at late times and no narrow interstellar lines are observed in the spectra. The faint absolute magnitude of SN 1991bg is established beyond doubt by comparison with SN 1957B, another type Ia supernova in the same galaxy, which was 2.5 magnitudes brighter than SN 1991bg. The spectral evolution reveals minor differences near maximum compared to other well-observed SNe Ia, mainly in relative line strengths. At later phases several wavelength regions display discrepancies when compared to spectra of normal SNe Ia. Although other SNe Ia, such as SN 1986G and SN 1939B, have light curves with fast decline rates, SN 1991bg is unique, with deviations in both light curves and spectra. In particular SN 1991bg is the only SN Ia observed to date with a distinct spectrum at ~40 days past maximum. Although SN 1991bg is an extreme case, with unusual photometric and spectroscopic properties, we believe it can be understood in the context of exploding white dwarf models, and is properly grouped with type Ia. SN 1991bg demonstrates the need for detailed observations of SNe Ia as part of their use as standard candles for cosmology. While there is a well-defined prototype with homogeneous properties, unusual cases like SN 1991bg must be identified and separated to avoid misleading results.