Effect of thermal diffusion on the stability of strongly tilted mantle plume tails

Abstract

The effect of thermal diffusion on the stability of strongly tilted mantle plume tails is explored by investigating experimentally and numerically the gravitational instability of a rising horizontal cylindrical region of buoyant viscous fluid. At large viscosity ratios, we find that the instability is unaffected by diffusion when the Rayleigh number Ra is greater than about 300. When Ra is less than 300, diffusion significantly increases the time for instability, as the rising fluid region needs to grow substantially by entrainment before it becomes unstable. When Ra is less than about 140 and the rise height available H is less than about 40 times the cylinder radius, the rising region of fluid is unable to grow sufficiently and instability is prevented. When our results are applied to the Earth, we predict that thermal diffusion will stabilize plume tails in both the upper and lower mantle. We also predict that some of the buoyancy flux in mantle plumes is lost during ascent to form downstream thermal wakes in any larger-scale mantle flow. Show more