Who owns it? Three arguments for land claims in latin America [¿A quién le pertenece? Tres argumentos para el reclamo de tierras en América Latina]
Date
2017
Authors
Barry, Christian
Overland, Gerhard
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile
Abstract
Indigenous and non-indigenous communities in Latin America make land claims and support them with a variety of arguments. Some, such as Zapatistas and the Mapuche, have appealed to the “ancestral” or “historical” connections between specific communities and the land. Other groups, such as MST in Brazil, have appealed to the extremely unequal distribution of the land and the effects of this on the poor; the land in this case is seen mainly as a means for securing a decent standard of living for members of disadvantaged groups. Although there is a large literature on the history as well as the social and political dimensions of land contestations and conflicts in Latin America, the question of whether the land claims put forward by disadvantaged groups can be morally justified has not been adequately examined. In this essay, we investigate the scope and limits of appeals to what we shall call assistance-based, contribution-based, and benefitting-based moral reasons with respect to land claims made by these disadvantaged groups.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Collections
Source
Revista de Ciencia Politica
Type
Journal article
Book Title
Entity type
Access Statement
Open Access
License Rights
Restricted until
Downloads
File
Description