Measuring helium nano-bubble formation in tungsten with grazing-incidence small angle X-ray scattering

Abstract

The behaviour of helium in tungsten is an important concern for the fusion materials community. Under helium plasma exposure, small nano-scale bubbles form beneath the material surface as helium precipitates from the tungsten matrix. Under certain conditions this can lead to the subsequent formation of a surface “nano-fuzz”, though the mechanisms of this process are not presently understood. For sub-surface nano-bubble formation transmission electron microscopy (TEM) has been the most widely used technique. While certainly a powerful technique, TEM suffers from a number of significant drawbacks: sample preparation is difficult and destructive, and there are sampling limitations as nano-structures must be located and characterised individually. This makes quantitative characterisation of nano-scale modification in tungsten challenging, which in turn makes it difficult to perform systematic studies on the effects of factors such as temperature and plasma composition on nano-scale modification. Here, Grazing Incidence Small Angle X-ray Scattering (GISAXS) is presented as a powerful addition to the field of fusion materials. With GISAXS, one can measure the X-ray scattering from nano-scale features throughout a relatively large volume, allowing information about full nano-bubble size distributions to be obtained from a simple, non-destructive measurement. Where it typically takes days or weeks to prepare a sample and study it under TEM, GISAXS measurements can be performed in a matter of minutes, and the data analysis performed autonomously by a computer in hours. This thesis describes the work establishing GISAXS as a viable technique for fusion materials. A GISAXS pattern fitting model was first developed, and then validated via comparison between GISAXS and TEM measurements of helium induced nano-bubble formation in tungsten exposed to a helium discharge in the large helical device. Under these conditions, nano-bubbles were found to follow an approximately exponential diameter distribution, with a mean nano-bubble diameters μ=0.596±0.001 nm and μ=0.68±0.04 nm computed for GISAXS and TEM, respectively. Depth distributions were also approximately exponential, with average bubble depths estimated at τ=9.1±0.4 nm and τ=8.4±0.5 for GISAXS and TEM, respectively. GISAXS was then applied to study the effects of plasma fluence, sample temperature and large transient heat and particle loads on nano-bubble formation. Nano-bubble sizes were found to saturate with increasing fluence at fluences less than 2.7×〖10〗^24 He/m^2 at 473 K. At higher temperatures larger nano-bubbles are able to form, suggesting a shift in the growth mechanisms, possibly from vacancy capture to bubble coalescence. Evidence is also presented which indicates that nano-bubble size distributions are qualitatively different for tungsten exposed to transient heat and particle loads due edge localised modes (ELMs) in the DIII-D tokamak, with a relatively large population of smaller (0.5-1 nm) nano-bubbles forming in this case. This is posited to be a consequence of rapid precipitation due to either extremely high helium concentrations during the ELM, or rapid cooling after it. Finally, synergistic effects between plasma composition and sample temperature are explored to determine which factors are most relevant for hydrogen and helium retention. Here, evidence has been found that helium ions from the plasma require a minimum energy of 9.0±1.4 eV in order to be implanted into tungsten. This was the dominant factor governing helium retention in this experiment. On the other hand, sample temperature is the dominant factor for hydrogen retention. Show more