Audit Firm Tenure and Audit Quality in a Constrained Market

Date

2018

Authors

Azizkhani, Masoud
Daghani, Reza
Shailer, Greg

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Pergamon Press

Abstract

We examine the relation between audit quality and audit firm tenure in the Iranian audit market, which is constrained by government policies that create intense competition for clients among many small audit firms. We develop arguments that these circumstances create cost pressures that entrench low audit quality and render auditors’ plans more predictable to managers wishing to misstate their accounts. Using publicly available data for the audits of listed companies in Iran prior to mandatory audit firm rotation and the incidence of misstated financial reports identified by the Iranian Association of Certified Public Accountants Inspection Office, we find that the likelihood of a misstatement is lowest in the first two years of audit firm tenure. We also find that the likelihood of misstatement is not associated with the year preceding a mandatory audit firm rotation, suggesting outgoing auditor effort is not sensitive to the prospect of subsequent revelations of deficiencies. Although our results from a pre-mandatory rotation period show that frequent rotations appear to improve the financial reporting quality in our sample, we are wary of interpreting these results as support for the mandatory audit firm rotation policy in Iran. Rather, we suggest this is a peculiar consequence of deficiencies in audit quality inherent in the Iranian market.

Description

Keywords

Audit quality, Audit firm tenure, Auditor competition, Misstatements

Citation

Source

The International Journal of Accounting

Type

Journal article

Book Title

Entity type

Access Statement

License Rights

DOI

10.1016/j.intacc.2018.07.002

Restricted until

2099-12-31