A New Method for Relating Zircon Crystallisation to Petrogenetic Events

Abstract

The trace element contents of zircon can provide unique insights into tectonothermal events, however, interpreting these data and identifying correlations with specific magmatic/metamorphic events can be challenging. This limits our ability to construct temporally constrained petrogenetic histories of complex metamorphic terranes. Unlocking the information that the rare earth element (REE) patterns of zircon contain is difficult because of the need to quantify differences. We have parametrised the shape of zircon REE patterns in terms of three independent parameters: average abundance, slope, and curvature. Quantifying REE patterns using independent shape parameters is similar to the use of REE ratios but is an improvement as (1) it uses information from all 14 REE rather than just two; (2) the use of two independent parameters (e.g. slope and curvature) is a more robust discriminant than the use of a single ratio; and (3) subtle variations in shape are easily distinguished enabling trends in the REE patterns of large datasets to be identified. Quantitative models were constructed showing how the shapes of the REE patterns of zircon change due to the co-crystallisation of other metamorphic minerals (monazite, apatite, and garnet). Diagnostic changes in shape enable the REE contents of zircon crystals or crystal zones to be accurately related to the growth of specific minerals and hence metamorphic events. The results were used to interpret the REE patterns of zircons from high-grade metamorphic terranes, which have experienced multiple deformation events (Val Malenco, Italy; Betic Cordillera, Spain; Seram, Indonesia; Lewisian Gneiss Complex, Scotland; Napier Complex, East Antarctica) and clearly identified zircon that crystallised in the presence of garnet. Quantitative comparison enabled zircon that crystallised prior to, synchronously with, or after garnet to be identified. Similar models can be used to interpret the REE patterns of monazite. This allows the relative timing of the growth of these minerals to be accurately constrained, which given the importance of zircon for geochronology and garnet for geobarometry has the potential to provide insights into the evolution of a metamorphic event.