The concept of open-book assessment is inherently controversial, not least because
it contradicts a basic condition of examinations, one so basic to the event that we
rarely question it: the single confrontation of examinee with exam question, the
element of isolated and unaided struggle—Jacob wrestling with the mysterious
Other. Surely it is cheating to allow texts into an exam-hall? What is the point of the
Items in Open Research are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.